Total Questions : 1
-
Case Study
You are the Superintendent of Police in a district known for its complex social dynamics and occasional communal tensions. Recently, a prominent religious leader from the majority community was arrested for alleged hate speech against minority groups. The arrest, though legally justified, has sparked widespread protests and unrest among his followers, who claim it's a politically motivated action.
As tensions escalate, you receive intelligence that a group of extremists is planning to vandalize minority-owned businesses and places of worship in retaliation. Your sources suggest that arresting the key instigators before they act could prevent the violence. However, you also learn that one of the main orchestrators is the son of a powerful state minister. Your immediate superior, the Inspector General, subtly hints that proceeding with these preventive arrests might negatively impact your career prospects, suggesting instead to increase general police presence and deal with any incidents "as they occur."
As the clock ticks and tensions rise, you must make a decision that balances your duty to maintain law and order, your career aspirations, and the complex social dynamics of your district.
1. Who are the key stakeholders involved in this situation?
2. What are the ethical dilemmas involved in this situation?
3. What will be your course of action, considering the potential risks to public safety, political pressure, and your ethical responsibility.
GS Paper 4 Case Studies
