Mains Marathon 2024

Approach Start with a concise explanation of John Rawls's theory of social justice. Discuss the key concepts of Rawls's Theory. Asses its relevance to the Indian Context. Conclude Suitably.

Introduction

John Rawls (1921–2002) was an American philosopher renowned for his work in political philosophy and ethics. His most influential contribution is his theory of justice, as presented in his landmark book “A Theory of Justice (1971)”. Rawls's theory is built around the idea of creating a just society by ensuring fairness through impartial principles.

Body

Key Concepts of Rawls's Theory of Justice :

• Original Position and Veil of Ignorance:
  • Rawls introduces the concept of the "original position," a hypothetical scenario where individuals, under a "veil of ignorance," design the principles of justice without knowledge of their own socio-economic status, talents, or personal attributes.
  • This thought experiment is intended to ensure that the principles chosen are fair and impartial, as individuals would make decisions that protect their interests regardless of their eventual position in society.
• Two Principles of Justice:
  • Equal Basic Liberties: The first principle asserts that each person should have an equal right to the most extensive basic liberties compatible with similar liberties for others. This includes freedoms such as speech, assembly, and religion.
  • Difference Principle: The second principle allows for social and economic inequalities only if they are arranged to benefit the least advantaged members of society. This principle seeks to balance the need for economic efficiency and individual freedoms with the goal of improving the welfare of the most disadvantaged.
• Justice as Fairness:
  • Rawls terms his approach "justice as fairness." He argues that a just society is one where social and economic inequalities are structured in a way that they benefit everyone, particularly those who are less fortunate.
  • The theory emphasizes the importance of fairness and equity in designing social institutions and policies.

Relevance to the Indian Context :

• Affirmative Action and Reservations :
  • India has implemented reservation policies to improve access to education and employment for Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs).
  • These policies align with Rawls's difference principle, which allows for inequalities only if they benefit the least advantaged.
• Economic Development Programs :
  • The Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (MGNREGA) provides a legal guarantee for at least 100 days of wage employment per year to rural households.
  • This program reflects the difference principle by aiming to improve the livelihoods of the rural poor, who are among the least advantaged in India.
• Social Welfare Schemes
  • Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) is a government scheme aimed at providing affordable housing to the economically weaker sections (EWS) and low-income groups (LIG) in urban areas.
• Health Care Initiatives :
  • The Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana (AB-PMJAY) provides health insurance coverage of up to ₹5 lakh per family per year for secondary and tertiary hospitalization.
  • This health care initiative aligns with Rawls’s principles by improving access to essential health services for low-income families, who are often the least advantaged.
• Education Reforms
  • The RTE Act mandates free and compulsory education for children aged 6 to 14 years and aims to improve educational access for marginalized groups.
  • This act is in line with Rawls’s principle of equal basic liberties, as it ensures that all children, regardless of their socio-economic background, have the right to education.

Criticism and Challenges :

• Reservation Policies:
  • Despite their intent, reservation policies sometimes face criticism for perpetuating identity-based politics and not fully addressing the needs of the most disadvantaged.
• Economic Development Programs:
  • Programs like MNREGA may face issues of inefficiency, corruption, and insufficient coverage, which can undermine their effectiveness in improving the conditions of the least advantaged.
• Social Welfare Schemes:
  • Implementation challenges, including bureaucratic inefficiencies and inadequate infrastructure, can affect the reach and impact of schemes like PMAY and Ayushman Bharat.
• Idealized Nature: While the veil of ignorance and the original position provide a thought-provoking framework for considering principles of justice, these concepts face significant criticisms for their abstract nature, assumptions about rationality, neglect of power dynamics, and challenges in practical application.

Conclusion

While Rawls’s theory may not fully capture the complexities of the Indian context, it still provides valuable insights. Adapting Rawlsian principles to address specific socio-economic and cultural issues in India, and integrating them with other relevant theories, such as Amartya Sen’s capability approach, could enhance their applicability.